Amit Paul Insipid, Emon Good, Prashant Improved
Posted On Saturday, August 04, 2007 at at 17:24 by rk rishikesh sinhaThe gala just went without any masti, music..
NEW DELHI,INDIA
Friends!! How was Amit Paul's performance in the folk music based programme of the Indian Idol III? Definitely, I am not happy and you will agree with me. He was not only irresponsible and didn't paid effort, but his voice was flat and not suitable to sing folk songs. Isn't?
In my previous posts I have praised him, but this time I am not going to praise him but dumb him. Read previous posts. It is understandable his voice doesn't go for folk songs, but one thing which really disturbed me was he forgot a part of the Omkara song.
He must know that people have the habit to forget things very fast. He was fabulous with Pehla…Nasha….from the movie Jo Jeeta Wahi Sikander and Nasha…Ye… Pyar… Ka Nasha …from the movie Mann.
Barring few, no doubt the judges praised him. But don't you think they have built up an emotional bondage for that reason they did not notice all those mistakes he was doing. And, we the audience had to languish with his insipid singing capability.
Prashant Tamang sang well, Emon was fanstastic, and almost every singer were in their best form.Not to mention girls performance in this gala. They showed their mettle.
Emon's As Usual
Emon's was flawless. Yes he was perfect..and showed that technically speaking no one can beat him in his home ground. He has the power to recuperate and give a tough fight. He is an accomplished singer. Not one time "wonder boy" who spell magic once and later vanish in oblivion. He is one of the pillars on which the Indian Idol III is standing upon.
Prashant Tamang is back
Yes, the most shy contestant, Prashant Tamang is back with Boomro...Booomro, a song from the movie Mission Kashmir. Though I don't like his song, but it is who gives me the inspiration that one must be truthful to himself, and of his interest. He is so cute, simple, with no vanity lingering around him. He seems the same person from Darjeeling, donning a police dress. I don't think there is anyone in the Indian Idol who has worked or has been in the job before. He is a natural, uncarved singer. In persosal front I didn't like his song, and the way he sang. I found he was correct in the pronunciation. There were many words which had a Nepali impression.
Lets wait for another round of a gala and see who rocks..and who were stale...
view video of Omkara
I completely agree with you. I was truly looking forward to Amit paul's performance but was disappointed big time! True that his voice is not suitable for folk songs but thats a different issue all together. It seemed like he didnt put in enough effort..maybe with all the praise he has become confident of winning and hence this lack of effort...Time to buck up dude!
Completely agreed with you!!! He was completely off colour in the Omkara performance. As he himself acceptedd, he was expecting something to go wrong there. There was some spprehensions and because f that he wasnt singing freely!! Truly speaking, Nasha ye pyaar ka nashe hai from mann and Pehla Nasha from jo jeeta wahi sikandaar was rocking performances. Thanks to his huge fan following because of these two performances, he was saved. Or else, I think going performance wise, he was definitely in the bottom four!!!
Emon was simply the best of all according to me!! Especially in the last two galas, with is pyaar ko kya naam doon from mujhe kuch kehna hai and the current one!!! I think he has to be in the top 3!!!
About Prashant, this is the performance which should get him back into the race!!! Previous ones were not upto the maark!!